"The vivid colors of the acrylic-and-watercolor
illustrations and pages bordered with motifs from Aztec art give the tale an
authentic flavor. A good choice to introduce children to a culture
underrepresented in picture books."
—Booklist,
April 1, 2008
"Aviles uses acrylics and liquid watercolor, as well
as motifs from Aztec art, in the brightly patterned illustrations. She changes
the placid, blue-green sea in the opening pages to a truly frightful place at
the end. Kimmel reminds readers that "the great turtle still swims in the
sea" and asks what they might wish for. Pair this story with Margaret Read
MacDonald’s The Old Woman Who Lived in a Vinegar Bottle (August House,
1997) or a version of the Grimm brothers’ "The Fisherman and His
Wife" for an interesting exploration of the same folktale in different
cultures."
—School
Library Journal,
May 2008